“They came in and wanted us to stop singing during the collection.”
“We were quite happy, everyone providing their own cup for the Lord’s Supper. Then a brother from the States brought us communion trays, without asking. Now we have to find ways to get cups from the States.”
“They questioned why we were using wine in the Lord’s Supper instead of grape juice.”
Just three stories I heard while in Cuba last week. Sad stories, to me. Tony Fernández told of preachers that change what they teach to align themselves with those that give them money. Of divisions being imported from outside the country. Of churches that become dependent on money and supplies from the States for everything they do.
Some of it I even saw firsthand. On the last day of the preacher’s conference, numerous people were invited to say something at the end. They were the typical speeches given at such times, words of thanks and words of encouragement. Then one brother from the States was asked if he would like to say something, and he replied, “Yeah, I’ve got a few things I want to say.” Then he proceeded to lambast the Cubans for two things, one which was a misunderstanding (the gentleman is hard of hearing) and the other a personal preference (he didn’t think people should clap for the speakers at the conference).
I was furious. Fortunately, 95% of the people there immediately rejected what this man had said. I fear, though, for the handful of preachers that receive their support from this man’s hand. I’m guessing they’ll feel pressured to complain about the same things in the future.
When I go to Cuba, I’m a foreigner. More than I am when here in Texas. I’ve spent a lifetime studying the Bible, and I have opinions and insights that I want to share. It’s so hard to not want to try and shape the Cuban church into what I think it should be. I think part of it even comes from the fact that we feel that we have a better chance of effecting change in these smaller, younger churches than we do in the churches where we are members. But we all have to learn to fight that tendency.
It’s hard for me. I’m guessing it’s hard for most people. But we’ve got to let the Cuban people develop their own faith, not just mirror our practices and statements of belief. We’ve got to do that around the world.
Isn’t that what Acts 15 is about? Romans 14? Let’s have enough faith in the power of God’s Word and the sanctifying work of the Spirit to allow people to grow into what God wants them to be, not what we think they should be.
By the way, if you’ve never read Pablo Sanabria’s open letter to American churches from the October 2006 issue of the Christian Chronicle, you should read it. I’ll end with a few quotes from his letter:
Brethren in the United States, please allow the leaders of the Nicaraguan churches to resolve their differences in their own cultural context.
Stop exporting your quarrels. Stop putting conditions on your support based on the acceptance of your personal points of view.
If you cannot stop requiring that local preachers reproduce your doctrinal theories, then consider the possibility of completely dropping the salaries that you send to Nicaragua.
Maybe this will help to reestablish the unity of church leaders that I once knew and participated in. Maybe this will help the church to once again flourish in this part of the world.
Man…this stuff makes me feel weary, but also glad that I’m not part of that scene any more.
May God keep me from imposing my views, however strongly felt, on those just seeking to serve him.
It’s so easy to get sucked into that mindset.
Tim what you observed and are aware of is happening all over the world. My last visit to Nigeria I worshiped with a church that uses “our” imported songs books and they sang the songs with the same state side sound to them. The song leader could have fit right into any of our more conservatives churches…hand movements and all. God help us!
Tim, your comments are always valuable and well thought out, but this may be one of your best! I think some of what we do to our missionaries is simply due to ignorance, but much more is just flat out imperialism. I just feel sorry for the victims – and pray that some day they will have the strength to see through our Americanizing practices.
Thanks!
Tim,
I’m glad you raised this issue. We too often want to import our cultural forms of church and call it gospel. This happens even within the US. Many of the Churches of Christ in the north are nothing more than clones of a southern rural CoC from places like Tennessee or Texas and that is one of the major reasons why they have never grown.
Out of curiosity, have you ever read Vincent J. Donavan’s “Christianity Rediscovered” (http://www.amazon.com/Christianity-Rediscovered-Vincent-J-Donovan/dp/1570754624)? As a person with cross-cultural mission experience, you would really enjoy the book. Donavan was a Catholic missionary in Tanzania and this book, which is very auto-biographical about his mission to Masai Indians, tells about the struggle to not import cultural forms of the gospel but to allow an indigenous expression of the gospel to be planted and blossom. It is one of my favorite books to read.
Grace and Peace,
Rex
I am dismayed at these kinds of things. Saddened too.