Tag Archives: labels

What’s in a label?

liberalThere’s a tried and true tactic in social movements, and that’s the proper use of naming. Give your movement the right name, and you’re well on the way to success. Stick your opponents with a poisoned moniker, and they’ll struggle to overcome that disadvantage.

A few examples come to mind:

  • Gender justice. If you hold to a certain point of view regarding the participation of women in Christian worship, you can lay claim to speaking for gender justice. That means that any who disagree with you are opposing justice. Wow! That’s powerful.
  • Homophobia. If you feel that homosexual activity is wrong, you are labeled as being scared of homosexuals. I heard that come into play the other day on a sports talk radio program. They were blasting Baylor over their conservative policies about homosexuality, making jokes about how Baylor thinks homosexuality is contagious. All because of the confusion from that word: homophobia.
  • Illegal aliens. I can’t think of another legal situation where the offender themselves is labeled “illegal.” But that has a powerful impact on people’s views toward these immigrants, which is why the pro-immigrant movement works hard to make “undocumented worker” the accepted term.
  • Liberal. I find this in many discussions, where people will say, “I’m so tired of those liberal arguments.” Or the example of Ann Coulter, who informed the world that conservative pastors who support immigration reform are liberals in disguise. Even in the church, the term liberal is applied to mark opposing ideas as potentially toxic.

Lots of other examples can be given… which come to your mind?

Labels, labels, labels

“I never call Christians or others ‘anti’s,’ ‘digressives, ‘ mossbacks,’ ‘tackies,’ or ‘trash.’ I concede to all, and accord to all, the same sincerity and courtesy I claim for myself, as the Golden Rule demands…” T.B. Larimore

As I’ve taken another look at Restoration History the last few years, I’ve become a fan of T. B Larimore. I’d love to be known as a man who refuses to take sides and who refuses to label others. It wasn’t until recently that I realized that the church where I grew up in San Angelo, Texas, was basically started through a one-month gospel meeting by T. B. Larimore. I guess some of his views were imparted to me from very young. One of those views is a deep-set distrust of labels.

Conservative. Liberal. Change agent. Anti. Progressive. Digressive… who wears what label depends on who is speaking. It’s rare that someone applies a label to himself. I’ve been called sectarian. I’ve been called liberal. I’ve been called a legalist. I’ve even been called evil (I’m sure that e-mail was sent in Christian love!). And all for expressing basically the same ideas. It just depends on where the other person is standing. In the big scheme of things, it really doesn’t matter what others say:“But with me it is a very small thing that I should be judged by you or by any human court. In fact, I do not even judge myself. I am not aware of anything against myself, but I am not thereby acquitted. It is the Lord who judges me.” (1 Cor 4:3-4) Still, I hate to see people resort to labels. There are several reasons why:

  1. When we resort to labels, we’ve stopped viewing the other person as an individual. We judge them in terms of other people, not according to what they actually think and believe.
  2. When we resort to labels, we stop listening. “Everything you’ve got to say, I’ve heard before from others just like you.”
  3. When we resort to labels, we tend to fall back on preset ways of reacting. “Post-modernists think this way, and here’s what I always say to them.” If I were to accept anything that a “post-modernist” says, I’d be accepting everyone else to whom I’ve given that label.

So here’s one suggestion for preserving the integrity of our Lord’s church: stop the labeling!

If you want to heal wounds in the Lord’s Church today,
Gather all of your labels and put them away.
If you have to use labels, I suggest these and few others:
Christians, fellow saints, disciples and brothers.