Tag Archives: relief

Help that harms

5 Replies

Tony Campolo wrote an excellent article last week that ties together several things that I’ve written about on this blog. He points out the harm that Christian relief has done in Haiti, not only now, but over the last few decades. He also reminds us that the hot trends in mission trips (building houses, etc.) aren’t helping the people we intend to help.

Really dealing with poverty takes long-term planning and carefully thought-out strategies. It’s not simple.

Maybe I’m just playing the role of Chicken Little, crying that the sky is falling when everyone knows that it’s not. Or maybe I’m able to see that the emperor has no clothes. Whichever it is, at least Tony Campolo agrees with me. Misery loves company.

Edit: (3/8/10, 9:45 a.m. CST) — Jay Guin’s blog reminded me that I could well include a couple of resources here:

  • When Helping Hurts by Steve Corbett and Dr. Brian Fikkert of the Chalmers Center for Economic Development and the Department of Economics and Community Development at Covenant College
  • Tending to Eden by Scott Sabin

Relief efforts and Christian priorities

17 Replies

There’s something else that concerns me about our rush to send relief to disaster areas. I’m wondering if we aren’t focusing a bit on the wrong things.

Again, I know that I’m running the risk of sounding calloused and uncaring. I recognize the need to reach out to hurting people. But I’m wondering if the materialism of the culture we are living in hasn’t made it easier for us to focus on physical things than spiritual ones.

Look at the society around us. Have you noticed that spirituality has nothing to do with wanting to help out with disasters? I’m not saying that makes it bad; I’m saying that it’s not something uniquely Christian.

But didn’t Jesus say to help the hurting? Of course he did. But never at the expense of our mission to the world. The unique thing that we have to offer is the good news of Jesus Christ. We’ve got to hang on to that, even as the world drives us to focus on physical things (good and bad). We are called to focus on the unseen, not the seen, on the eternal, not the temporal.

I’ve often wished that we could somehow see the pictures of the spiritually starving, with bloated souls longing for nourishment. I’ve wanted to be able to show the earthquake of sin, the hurricane of wrongdoing that devastates family after family. In a materialistic society, we are moved by physical suffering and economic loss. We understand lack of food and water. Everyone is touched by these things, not just Christians. It’s part of survival, the “herd instinct” that makes someone dive into a swollen river to try and save a stranger.

We need some priorities. We need holistic programs that serve body and soul. We need to be willing to stick to longterm efforts, rather than jumping from emergency to emergency. If we feed and heal and house and clothe, yet don’t lead people to Christ, are we really doing them good in the long run? In the LONG run?

In 21st-century America, it’s easy to raise money for relief projects. Christians, non-Christians, everyone wants to give to help. At some point we need to ask ourselves, should the church look just like the world in this? Do we not have something more to offer, something more important?

If not, we should probably shut our doors.

3 lessons learned from hurricane relief to Cuba

1 Reply

After discussing concerns I have about the way the relief effort for Haiti has been handled, I wanted to mention some things that I observed after Cuba was hit by 4 hurricanes in 2008:

(1) We need to stay home. Well, maybe not everybody. But if you can’t go and offer a needed skill, you’re a hindrance, not a help. One man I know hurried to get down to Havana soon after the hurricanes went through. It was a time of terrible food shortages on the island. I’m sure that his presence encouraged some, but he was also using up precious resources that were needed by others. We feel a desperate need to do something, yet there are times when our attempts at helping only hurt.

(2) We need to trust the locals. People say, “Well, we need to go and make sure the money is spent right.” Whether we recognize it or not, there is a bit of ethnocentrism in that, a bit of the idea that “those folks just won’t know how to handle things.” One preacher from Panama told me about a building that a church from the States had built. They insisted on using an architect from the U.S., which increased the costs greatly because he wasn’t familiar with local building codes, local materials, nor local labor practices. We need to recognize that in most instances they will know better what they need than we will.

(3) Centralization and cooperation are powerful tools. Due to the nature of Cuban-U.S. relations, people from the States couldn’t go running down there. With the complicated processes involved in getting money to Cuba, it was only natural that the money sent by churches was pooled and overseen by a committee of Cuban church members. Rather than being distributed by agencies competing with one another for funds, the relief items were distributed through one central group.

The situation in Cuba is unique, however the lessons we can learn from what happened there can help us respond to other disasters, especially in the Caribbean.

My 3 big concerns about helping Haiti (and other disaster areas)

11 Replies

Am I the only one who gets a little uncomfortable when a certain type of relief becomes popular? It’s not easy to talk about, because it can make you sound so insensitive. And I’ll confess to having waited a few weeks so as not to distract from the task at hand. But now I want to point out three main concerns I’ve had over the last few weeks, not just about Haiti, but about knee-jerk emergency relief in general.

  1. Everybody and their dog starts raising money. The relief bandwagon gets pretty crowded. Any agency that is remotely connected to relief or the area in question begins collecting funds. Questions about distribution structure, contacts on the ground, etc. get overlooked. We want to help and are willing to give to anyone who says they are going to help.
  2. Inefficiency is permitted in the name of haste. Planning falls by the wayside. We want something done NOW. There is a need for quick response, but does that excuse spending twice as much to get the same thing done?
  3. Good projects lose funding as money is funneled into the emergency bottleneck. Some of these projects are feeding people who will be in dire straits without the aid being provided. They are well-organized, efficient projects, but because they aren’t the latest big thing, they just aren’t as interesting.

Places like Haiti need our help. They need it quickly. But we need to think carefully about the best ways to make our donations do the most good.