I’ll continue the series on non-participation soon, but I’m not quite ready to do that.
In the meantime, I wanted to share something that has troubled me at times. It came up again this Memorial Day. When talking about soldiers and their sacrifices, people like to quote John 15:13—”Greater love has no one than this, that he lay down his life for his friends.”
It’s hard for me to connect the words of a man going to die on a cross with what soldiers do. One gave himself willingly over to his enemies; one prefers to see his enemies die rather than die himself. One died not only on behalf of his friends but also on behalf of his enemies (which would be us, according to Romans 5:10); it’s almost a given that soldiers work off of an us/them mentality.
As far as laying down one’s life, I rarely see soldiers choosing to give up their lives. Admittedly, they choose to risk their lives. But apart from suicide attacks, like the kamikaze pilots in WWII, few soldiers go into battle planning to lay down their lives.
It seems to me that using these words in this way ignores most of what Jesus was trying to say. Or am I wrong?